This post was from a user who has deleted their account.
something to add is that the elite adds that spawn in phase 2, are not something should avoid all the time. They gain the ability "Ignite Weapon" which does the 17.5/25.5k to all players within 5 yards of the target, so as long as melee are not sitting on the tank they should be able to dps the elite adds just fine. The blast nova is not something that is impossible for melee to watch either.
I have to thank (almost) all of you for the (in)direct feedback. I guess most of you were responding to other people, but I gathered quite a bit of info about the fight without actually going there (guild decided to stick with ToC, and 10-minute loading screens convinced us we should just call it a night). I am going to be updating the Strategist with the following information (let me know if I am missing something):
Awesome. I guess I'll either wait a couple of days to figure it out, or find a combat log.
My guild just downed her on the second try 25man normal. Most of the people didn't know the tactics that's why we wiped the first time. She is waaay to easy. The third phase is like a walk in the park compared to Anub'Arak's third phase who we downed just before Onyxia.I won the head, turned in the quest but no Onyxia head popped up at the Orgrimmar, strange.